First off, the service of Kate's Clothing was impeccable as usual. I gave the 4 stars for the candles only. The candles are lovely and black and burn clean but they don't bleed as well as shown in the pictures AND the red inside is more a dark burgundy. Still a lovely candle but not as lush as advertised. Also, you only get 4 in a pack so, I'm not sure of the value for money. If you need black candles though, they are nice.